New Trick or Treat items; Medusa Head, Skull Stack, Gargish Lantern
Two common and two rare types have been added to the list of possible Jack o’ Lanterns
| Year | Possible Gifts |
| 2006 | (Grim Reaper Loot)Twilight Lantern, Halloween Ghoul Statuette, The Grim Reaper’s Scythe Artifact Rarity 11 Hit Life Leech 100% Hit Harm 25% Spell Damage Increase 5% Damage Increase 50% Physical Damage 100% Weapon Speed 3.5s Weapon Damage: 15 – 18 Strgenth Requirement 45 Two-Handed Weapon Skill Required: Swordsmanship Durability 255/255 (trick or treat rewards) Caramel Apple, Candy, Licorice, Rock Candy, 9th Anniversary Cake, Milk, Bottle of Wine, Plate of Cookies, Pizza. (from fields) Lrg Sm Pumpkins, Small Jack O’ Lanterns, Large Jack O’ Lanterns |
| 2007 | (Grim Reaper Loot)Twilight Lantern, Halloween Ghoul Statuette (trick or treat) Candy red apple, Brightly colored rock candies, Black licorice, A plate of Mr. Plain’s Cookies, Pumpkin Pizza, Creepy Cake, Harvest Wine, Murky Milk |
| 2008 | (trick or treat) A Giant Pumpkin Muffin, Pixie Stick, Small Web, Creepy Cake, Harvest Wine, Mr. Plain’s Cookies, Murky Milk, Pumpkin Pizza, Red Caramel Apple, Dark Licorice, Rock Candy (from fields) Lrg Sm Pumpkins, Small Jack O’ Lanterns, Large Jack O’ Lanterns |
| 2009 | (event loot) Black Cat Statuette, Pumpkin Scarecrow, Ruined Tapestry (Trick or Treat)Jellybeans, Nougat Swirl, Taffy, Wrapped Candy, Cherry, Lime or Orange Lollipops, Creepy Cake, Harvest Wine, Murky Milk, Mr. Plain’s Cookies, Pumpkin Pizza, Small Web, Grim Warning, Skulls on a Pike(from fields) Lrg Sm Pumpkins, Jack O’ Lanterns |
| 2010 | (Trick or Treat) Jellybeans Jelly, Nougat Swirl, Taffy, Wrapped Candy, Cherry, Lime or Orange Lollipops, Creepy Cake, Grim Warning, Harvest Wine, Murky Milk, Mr. Plain’s Cookies, Skulls on a Pike, Chair in a Ghost Costume, Excellent Iron Maiden, Halloween Guillotine, Small Web (from fields) Lrg Sm Pumpkins, Jack O’ Lanterns |
| 2011 | (Trick or Treat) Jellybeans Jelly, Nougat Swirl, Taffy, Wrapped Candy, Cherry, Lime or Orange Lollipops, Creepy Cake, Grim Warning, Harvest Wine, Murky Milk, Mr. Plain’s Cookies, Skulls on a Pike, Chair in a Ghost Costume, Excellent Iron Maiden, Halloween Guillotine, Small Web (killer pumkin loot) Daemon Mask, Clown Mask, Plague Mask |
| 2012 | (Trick or Treat) Jellybeans Jelly, Nougat Swirl, Taffy, Wrapped Candy, Cherry, Lime or Orange Lollipops, Creepy Cake, Grim Warning, Harvest Wine, Murky Milk, Mr. Plain’s Cookies, Skulls on a Pike, Chair in a Ghost Costume, Excellent Iron Maiden, Halloween Guillotine, Small Web (killer pumkin loot) Daemon Mask, Clown Mask, Plague Mask, Evil Jester Mask, Porcelain Mask |
| 2013 | (Graveyard Butcher) Jack O` Lantern Carving Kit (Killer Pumpkins) Carvable Pumpkin(Trick or Treat) Jellybeans Jelly, Nougat Swirl, Taffy, Wrapped Candy, Cherry, Lime or Orange Lollipops, Creepy Cake, Grim Warning, Harvest Wine, Murky Milk, Mr. Plain’s Cookies, Skulls on a Pike, Chair in a Ghost Costume, Excellent Iron Maiden, Halloween Guillotine, Small Web, UO Team Member’s Head On A Spike |
| 2014 | (Graveyard Butcher) Jack O` Lantern Carving Kit (Killer Pumpkins) Carvable Pumpkin, Obsidian Skull, Crystal Skull, Jade Skull (Trick or Treat) Jellybeans Jelly, Nougat Swirl, Taffy, Wrapped Candy, Cherry, Lime or Orange Lollipops, Creepy Cake, Grim Warning, Harvest Wine, Murky Milk, Mr. Plain’s Cookies, Skulls on a Pike, Chair in a Ghost Costume, Excellent Iron Maiden, Halloween Guillotine, Small Web |
| 2015 | (Graveyard Butcher) Jack O` Lantern Carving Kit (Killer Pumpkins) Carvable Pumpkin (trick or treat) (Trick or Treat) Jellybeans Jelly, Nougat Swirl, Taffy, Wrapped Candy, Cherry, Lime or Orange Lollipops, Creepy Cake, Grim Warning, Harvest Wine, Murky Milk, Mr. Plain’s Cookies, Skulls on a Pike, Chair in a Ghost Costume, Excellent Iron Maiden, Halloween Guillotine, Small Web |
| 2016 | New items added:
(pumpkin patch) green gourd style pumpkin (2 designs when carved) |
| 2017 | New items added: (graveyards) new skeletons in a variety of styles with a chance of rare hues. (pumpkin patches) new round pumpkin to carve into two new designs, an owl and cat. (trick or treat) new treat, the flaming scarecrow. |
| 2018 | New items added: (graveyards) Should you die during this period you may find your zombie skeleton terrorizing the cemeteries (pumpkin patches) New styles of carvable pumpkins and jack o’ lanterns are available (trick or treat) A massive dragon jack o’ lantern house addon, 3 new crystal skulls, 3 funny face jack o’ lanterns |
| 2019 | Trick or Treating – added new crystal skulls to collect! Carvable Pumpkins – added new carving designs to collect! |
| 2020 | Carvable pumpkins – Two new Jack O’ Lanterns |
| 2021 | Trick or Treating – added new collectables, Medusa Head, Stack of Skulls, Gargish Lantern Carvable pumpkins – Two common and two rare Jack O’Lanterns added |
| 2022 | Trick or Treating – Pumpkin Centerpiece (plays a scary sound when locked down and activated inside a house), Black Pumpkin (can be hued with dyes, pigments & Natural dyes) Carvable pumpkins – 3 new styles of Jack o’ Lanterns possible Graveyards – additional hues for rare skeletons |